I am posting this at 6:18 AM On Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Captain Martin then made you Brigade S2? Lim: Yes. Def: When did he take over? #Manning |
1 minute ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: How long as Asst Brigade? Lim: Oct 2007 - January 2010. Feb 6 Changed Command. #Manning |
3 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: What sort of interactions? Lim: Little bit of interactions. Lance dealt mostly with HQ. #Manning |
4 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def (Coombs): Responsibilities. Lim: Attend meeting. Take his requests and issue tasks. #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def (Coombs): You were Asst Brigade S2 Oct 2009 and MI Commander at same time? Lim: Yes. #Manning |
7 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def (Coombs): Who was the approving authority? Lim: Brigade Commander. #Manning |
8 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Only those that absolutely cannot? Lim: Yes. Def: To not take someone what protocol? Lim: Chain of Command. #Manning |
9 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def (Coombs): Pressured to take people to meet numbers? Lim: Due diligence to take as many people as you can. cont #Manning |
9 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: All able body persons, not w pending medical issues. #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Who was not deployed? What guidance did you receive on who not to deploy? #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: All source intel officers transferred? Lim: Yes. Since 2002? Yes. Human intel. Signal Intel. #Manning |
12 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs first speaks about the deployment. Def: Duties? Lim: Battalion SL MI Commander. One Commander per Brigade Combat Team. #Manning |
13 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
There was a parlay about relevance. [I wrote down that the IO overruled, but I am not certain if that is accurate.] #Manning |
18 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Would you say PFC #Manning has brough discredit on the Army? Lim: Yes. DEFENSE OBJECTED to line of question. |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: In 6 years have you had soldiers with minor behavioral issues? Lim: yes. Did you permanently remove? Lim: No #Manning |
21 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: #Manning security changed to derogatory (derog) after assault on Spec. Schulman (sp.) |
23 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Then Lim talks about how #Manning was placed from SCIF to Supply section while he was on environmental leave so he only heard about it. |
25 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim cont answering: Brigade S2 not given. Action wasn't drastic enough to remove him. We needed analysis. We needed work. #Manning |
27 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Result? Lim: Took #Manning to a behavioral specialist. #Manning |
27 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: From my knowledge. Night time supervisor on reprimand for arriving late. #Manning flipped table. |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec then leads to question to behavioral incidents by #Manning |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont Signed non disclosure agreements. #Manning |
31 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont Signed non disclosure agreements. #Manning |
1 minute ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What prevented soldiers from burning CD? Lim: Well we can't watch every person, 24 hours a day. #Manning |
2 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
[Note He referred to special soldiers on the ground, I believe who were reporting information. Double check against Rainey's] #Manning |
3 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont.... Only special soldiers have direct log onto segregated info. #Manning |
4 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How is classified info detected? Lim: Those who didn't have access, no passcode. #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Centcom Web site? Lim: Maybe. Prosec: Centcom legal? Lim: No. Prosec: GTMO detainee assessments? Lim: No. #Manning |
7 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Work related searches? Iceland? Lim: No. Prosec: Julian #Assange? Lim: No. Prosec: 15 , 6? Lim: No. #Manning |
8 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Do you know anything about netcentric diplomacy? Lim: No. #Manning |
10 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: #Manning weakness? Lim: Trying to get point across. Public speaking. |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Yes. If you didn't use system a lot...took some technique, and a lot of practice. #Manning |
12 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Is this the type of process referenced to data mining? #Manning |
12 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Easy process? Lim: Statistics yes. Not easy. Challenging system to use. #Manning |
13 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: #Manning's strengths? Lim: Statistics. Predictive analysis. Putting that into ArcMap to give visual picture. |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Could an individual create that work product alone? Lim: no. Based off Commander needs not individuals. #Manning |
16 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Did #Manning ever investigate IEDs from Shia attacks? Lim: Yes |
18 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How is that information accessible? Lim: Able to pull data of historical attacks from Sydney. #Manning |
19 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What type of threat did Shia pose? Lim: 1 to 5 attacks a day. #Manning |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont...because that was part of our mission to train how to use and share information with Iraqis. #Manning |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: That was a specific caveat....partnered with Iraq. We were auth to release to Iraqi defense forces. #Manning |
22 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Classified harddrive? Lim: Yes. We had info that was releasable to Iraqis, translated for Iraqi soldier in Arabic. #Manning |
23 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: siprnet secret? Lim: Yes. Prosec: D6 Secret? Lim: Yes. Prosec: Were computers you had on network? Lim: Yes. #Manning |
24 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Could you get onto network in SCIF did you have siprnet? Lim: Yes. Prosec: What else? Lim: niprnet siprnet #Manning |
25 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Where was your office located? Lim: Command Group. Prosec: Anyone in brigade top secret? Lim: They work on signal intel. #Manning |
27 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: #Manning was focused on 'Shia threat' basd on attack patterns on Shia enemy at Fob Hammer, Iraq. |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
[NOTE: Lim made reference to some analyst placed on 'Sunni threat', some on 'Shia threat'. PR soundbite for Pentagon media plan?] |
32 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont Focused on enemy, help troops on the ground. Prosec: #Manning was on 'Shia threat'? He was put on "Shia"? |
35 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: When? Lim: January 2010. Replaced guy who could not explain to the commander in the way he needed. cont #Manning |
37 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Next line of questions related to when Lim was promoted. Lim: After Second GFC rotation. Once we were deployed. #Manning |
38 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont... Then go thru QIQC to make sure product is in line with intel. Then follow up. #Manning |
39 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: All historical analysis. Provide historic enemy activity. Put it all together in a product.... cont #Manning |
39 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Your job is to answer questions of your commander? Lim: Yes. #Manning |
40 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Commanders all rely on products...based off something he requests. #Manning |
41 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: what do you remember about #Manning? Lim: Not a lot. We were really busy. Prosec: Was everyone working on simulation? Lim: Yes. |
42 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Majority of units focus on enemy couple months before deployment (Alexa note: Meaning they practice search and analysis.) #Manning |
44 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How do they assist? Lim: QIQD Quality Insurane Quality Control. #manning |
44 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: In garrison environment duties are physical security, system security, assisting on inspection, not as much analysis #Manning |
45 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Why distinguish? #Manning |
45 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Querytree. Our secret version of Google. Prosec: How often do they use Sydney? Lim: In a combat environment, everyday. #Manning |
57 seconds ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Who uses it? Lim: All sorts of personel even medical. Prosec: Do 35Fox use Sydney too? Lim: Yes. #Manning |
2 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Sydney database is a combined info data network references all kinds - human intel, controlled debriefs, state dept debriefs #Manning |
3 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Why? Lim: When you are making a product, you need to nail down product. Sydney(sp.?) database, Querytree... #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What other systems? Lim: UADS, other ground base assets, data pulled into siprnet, conducting research to narrow down info #Manning |
6 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Make sure person has proper access. Should be common sense. We deal with more classified material. #Manning |
9 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Sharing what are the requirements? #Manning |
9 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Are 35Foxes trained on recognizing marks? Lim: Yes. #Manning |
10 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: Some security training. Classification privileges. How to mark. Making sure data labeled correctly. #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What kind of training do they receive in broad sense? #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont ... with Microsoft Office Suite, Geoplotting. Found on siprnet. #Manning |
13 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: cont... 2.) System. All source DGA system. Distributed Common Ground Army. Laptop terminal, where intel has all resources... #Manning |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Training? Lim: 1.) Collection on Systems. Aerial platforms. Ground base systems. collection platforms and devices #Manning |
16 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What does that mean? Lim: "Smarter than other soldiers." #Manning |
17 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: can any soldier get 35Fox...? Lim: Higher GI score than others. #Manning |
17 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How get Top Secret Clearance? Lim": Good credit. No past felonies. Good behavior. American citizen. #Manning |
18 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What are the pre-requisits for 35Fox...? Lim: Graduate AIT training. Top Secret clearance. #Manning |
18 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: #Manning? Lim: Intel Analyst w Brigade 35Fox identifier. |
19 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What job did you have at brigade? Lim: MI Co. Commander. Asst. Brigade S2. #Manning |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim:...My job JRTC major units to validate prior to deployment. Lim says he met #Manning second time in Iraq. |
21 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: 2008 Oct, and July 2009. We did two rotations 6 or 7 months, where going to go to Afghanistan. #Manning |
26 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What did you do? Lim: Used my small staff of Intel analysts with combat intel officer for operations. #Manning |
27 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: ...Final Fob Hammer, Iraq Prosec: When did you arrive? Lim: March 2006 Prosec: Position Lim: Infantry Battalion S2 #Manning |
28 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Duties as Intel? Lim: Second brigade. MI company command. Deployed 3x, 2x as Intel. All deployments Iraq. #Manning |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: 'Military intel Capt Career Course. Then graduate level advanced course Intel as Future Battalion Officers" #Manning |
31 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: "Army 9 years, Intel 5 years. Before Air defense officer." Prosec: Training? #Manning |
32 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim: 'Our job comprehensive intelligence products. Take different forms of intelligence to meet commanders needs to make decision.' #Manning |
33 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lim is currnt Deputy G2 at Fort Meade. Plan resources and training for reserves as they deploy. #Manning |
2 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Witness is permanently excused by court. Next Witness Lim. #Manning |
4 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Did you sit thru first block? Did u learn you can't transmit to someone unauthorized? Madrid: Yes. #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: All of the training? Madrid: Yes. #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: You had nothing to do w instruction byt sat thru Mardid: Yes. #Manning |
8 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: If they identify themselves w security clearance they can be targeted. #Manning |
8 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution re-examines. Prosec: Why shouldn't they use buzz words? #Manning |
9 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Do you know if his clearance was suspended. Madrid: No it was not. He could not have completed the course if it was. #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
[If I get locked out for overtweeting. Will continue on @devernaclep] Yesterday Part II of Day One is on @usdor which I had access to. |
16 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: So corrective training? Madrid: Yes. Def: Due to this, not so important that you suspend clearance? Madird: Don't have auth. #Manning |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Are 'SCIF' "Top Secret' 'Classified' buzzwords classified? Madrid: No but they are taught not to do it. #Manning |
23 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: Don't recall Def: Showed his barracks? March to class? Madrid: Yes. Def: How hard PT training was? Madrid: Yes. #Manning |
24 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Videos intended for friends and family? Madrid: Yes. Def: Did video say he missed his family? #Manning |
1 minute ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Video show ant classified info? Madrid: No, but he was using buzz words. Said they were classified. #Manning |
2 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Did you see all the videos that #Manning posted? Madrid: I saw one. Def: Showed it to Captain Ogeltree(sp.)? Madrid: Yes. #Manning |
4 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Expertise comes through honing skills? Madrid: yes, as with any job. #Manning |
4 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: Unreasonable to say they are an expert, but they are qualified by doctrine and standards. #Manning |
5 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid says he attends classes with soldiers. Def: When AIT graduate they have a baseline understanding reasonable? Madrid: Yes. #Manning |
7 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: But you know them. Def asks how much he actually participated in the class with soldiers being trained vis a vis field. #Manning |
8 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Part in field, part in classroom? Madrid: Yes. Def: Lots of students hard to get to know? Madrid: Don't get to know all... #Manning |
10 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: We spoke o the phone before? Madrid: Yes. Def: Platoon Sergeant at AIT? Madrid: Yes. Def: Course? MadridL 16 weeks 3 days. #Manning |
11 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense cross examines witness. #Manning |
12 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Personal NB Military Intel guys use term product a lot in forthcoming testimony. #Manning |
13 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: ...types - foreign govt, enemies, spies, hackers. Written product references to regulations. #Manning |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: ...How to handle it, if u r a person w access how it could be dangerous. There are sources looking for info on military. #Manning |
11 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: cont ...and the PPT for Friday formation. Prosec: Presentation for the unit what was that? Madrid: Infosec... cont #Manning |
13 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Other? Madrid: Typed out that he understood wasn't suppose to do that sort of thing divulge clearance, make himself target #Manning |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: cont... Soldier needed to present it to me first to make sure its an 'informative product' #Manning |
15 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What was your corrective training? Madrid: Presentation for Friday formation... cont #Manning |
16 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: This one video meant for fam and friends of #Manning inside barracks room "Well I work at this super secret SCIF, I handle...." |
18 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
[Personal note: Guy in a weird white van just pulled up next to me at McDonalds. Ted Bundy had a white van. My grandmother told me so.] |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madird: Soldiers said they saw 3 videos, couldn't access YouTube through work computer, so views only 1 on soldier's laptop. #Manning |
21 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: Soldiers informed him that #Manning was hosting videos on YouTube with titles like "classified" "Scif" "Top Secret" #Manning |
22 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Reason for corrective training? #Manning |
25 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Line of questions that lead Madrid to say in June 2008 he gave corrective training to #Manning. |
26 minutes ago |
marymad mary mad |
every time @carwinb says prosec, i think she is talking about the opposite of antisec. |
32 minutes ago |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How do you know? Madrid: I would talk to instructors. Prosec: Do you need interim clearance for class? Madird: Yes. Temp. #Manning |
28 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
back to it re first instruction ? ... Madrid: Info sec, how to handle and contain classification. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Personal note. I am doing this, because I want you here too, and you deserve to know what the fuck is going on. |
13 minutes ago Favorite Retweet Reply |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: MOS? Madrid: 35 Foxtrot Military Intelligence Analyst. Prosec: What is first instruction? #Manning |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: When did #Manning attend? Madrid: April - Aug 2008 Prosec: Platoon Sergeant? Madrid: Feb 08 to Aug 10 |
14 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Madrid: 2 years. I work on BMI systems to exploitation PDA, laptop, phones. Prosec: How do u know #Manning? Madrid: Platoon Sergeant. |
17 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: When retired? Madrid: 1 Sept 2010 Prosec: How many years? #Manning |
17 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Notes related to case? (not allowed, but can't verify) Madrid: No. IO gives speech re notifying him, if answer classified. #Manning |
20 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec Are you alone, can you speak freely? Madrid (sp.): Yes. #Manning |
21 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Next witness. Sargent First Class Brian Madrid (name need verification) By telephone. Sworn in by Overgaard of Prosecution. #Manning |
23 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO stops line of questions and tells Prosecution not to ask about #Manning guilt or innocence. |
23 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Then the prosecution as that if #Manning is guilty fo what he is accused of, he put people's lives at risk. Defense objects. #Manning |
25 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Pros: cont ...Do you believe ppl have responsibility to secure classified info? #Manning |
27 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Pros: You are CID? As CID you sign a non disclosure agreement for govt clearance... cont #Manning |
28 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution re-examines witness Chord. #Manning |
29 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord: I would with benefit of hindsight like to think I would have noticed his behavior and prevented him from deploying. #Manning |
30 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Opinion as to his military leadership? #Manning |
30 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord: Incident he assaulted a supervisor, incident he threw a computer, incident where he was found curled up in a ball. #Manning |
31 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Evidence of him exuding odd behavior? #Manning |
32 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: An individual interested in politics? Chord: Friends said they would have discussions pertaining to politics. #Manning |
33 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: During your work, was he tied to a known terrorist group? Chord: No. #Manning |
34 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Aware of him being gay? Chord: Yes. Def: Served in the military? Chord: Yes. Served for 12 years. #Manning |
35 minutes ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Next tweet on screen was dated Feb 16 2010 "Have a database...TREASURMAP" #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
wikileaks WikiLeaks |
Have encrypted videos of US bomb strikes on civilians http://bit.ly/wlafghan2 we need super computer time http://ljsf.org/ |
8 Jan 10 |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Detail: In #WikiLeaks logo of the tweets was Free Bradley and it showed up in the courtroom for #Manning to see. (Not sure if he noticed). |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Then on screen a #WikiLeaks tweet from dated January 8, 2010 "Have encrypted videos of US bombstrikes on civilians..." #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: What is twitter? Chord answers, I did not write it down. #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Did WL ever use social media? Chord: Yes. Very. Still. #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
cont ...Request for Camp Delta...interrogations #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
cont... Under military intel (from Most Wanted List) focus on CIA, detainee interrogations, rules of engagement... cont #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution shows archive of #WikiLeaks website with country listings eg, US [intellipdia, opensource.gov] ... cont #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Pnt I am trying to make re Way Back Machine, dates shown in the courtroom, are not available for me to show here. #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Sitting in a McDonald parking lot in my car eating french fries and diet coke. Ja. Ich bin Americanerin. Ok. Back to work here. |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
More to come. Need something to quench my thirst. 5 minutes. |
1 hour ago |
timeoutcorner Andrew McInnes |
@ |
@DrCin Confirmed on my end: Web, Icerock, and TweetDeck do not show @carwinb original tweets w/ #Manning or #WikiLeaks. @Asher_Wolf |
1 hour ago |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
#WikiLeaks 2010 Way Back Machine (Didn't right down date for May 2010 ) bit.ly/sLSYvP #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
#Wikileaks 2009 from Way Back. (Weird not there for Nov 5, 2009) #Manning bit.ly/uHU6AD |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
On a projected screen were shown a web archive they identified as from first from May 2010 and then Nov 5 2009. #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord then explains the Way Back machine. #Manning #Wikileaks. |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Did #WikiLeaks ever solicit? Chord: Put an update, "Most Wanted List" by country. #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO has no idea what the Icelandic Modern Media Initiative is. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Why Iceland? Chord: Iceland initiated Icelandic Modern Media Initiative. #Manning #WikiLeaks (Then IO asks to repeat words.) |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Where is it fiscally based? Chord: Wherever Mr. Assange is located. At one time it was Iceland. Now England. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Where are its servers? Chord: All over the world: Germany, Sweden, (names more countries) even Texas. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: WL a website? Chord: Yes, tech side is. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord: (You initiate, the web site then scans your computer for the file to upload) #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: How does one submit to the web site? (Chord then goes through the process verbally) #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord con't: Same time org existed, web site existed. (Goes on to explain they solicit) classified, decrypted.... #WikiLeaks #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What is #WikiLeaks dot org? Chord: WL founded in 2006 by an Australian national, bound to no gov entity. #Manning |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Have you testified? Chord: Cyber crimes. General crimes. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
1 hour ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: What training? Chord: Govt and Commercial providers. NCay Access Data DC3 (etc.) #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Job Chord: Special agent to intrusion team assigned to this. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Chord: Army CID prior Nov 2010 to December 2011 and then previous 2001 to 2005. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Where do u work? Chord: US Treasury. Prosec: What kind work? Chord: Forensic civil, criminal Interaction. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Next witness. Special agent Ben Chord. Testimony was accompanied by visual projection of archived #WikiLeaks web site and tweets. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Tech note: Just a heads up, I have noticed I don't show up in many hash tags since after Sept 17. |
2 hours ago |
USDayofRageFL Florida |
@ |
@carwinb I sent you an email. Something wrong. Your tweets for #Manning #WikiLeaks are not shown in either thread. |
2 hours ago |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): Not relevant? IO: No. You can bring it up with the judge when/if it goes to trial. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Investigating Officer (IO): At this point your request is denied. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): cont...and disclose State Dept, FBI, DOJ. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): If you deem it irrelevant, it does not stop at trial counsel. I would like that to go on record. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): What exactly does the govt have? 1.) Does it exist? 2.) Do they have authorization cont #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Corrected tweet. IO or Prosec who said "US does not have approval to turn over such evidence in possession of the FBI" #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): Defense should not be operating in a information vacuum. I request you obtain info for defense. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense (Coombs): This agent that was the FBI. Prosecutor deemed to have knowledge. Clearly that is the case. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
'As defense requested RCN45 collateral investigation of evidence by govt." #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense renewed request compel collateral evidence from DOJ... cont #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
USDayofRageFL Florida |
@ |
@carwinb know UR busy. FYI these tweets of yours are not showing up under the #Manning hashtag. |
2 hours ago |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Special Agent Mander excused. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Why? Mander: Trying to identify all evidence related to this investigation. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: How process worked? #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Again, forensic exam slow process, as items of investigation rpt'ed would contact ex co worker ask if they knew about info. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution (Overgaard): Defense brought up numerous individuals being interviewed multiple times. Why did that happen? #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution then re-examines the witness Mander. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(Alexa notes: What the fuck am I talking about? That is US NOW.) #NDAA |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(Alexa note: Listen up America, thats our soon to be with the #NDAA) |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont ...but by the time we figured that out, he had been transferred. #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...Went back to facility but only in regard to "safety and security" Violations of his confinement strategy... cont #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...mangistrate felt we did not need authorixation due to his status as confinee... cont #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander cont...Facility said we needed to have a search warrant. We contacted magistrate. There was a legal disagreement... cont #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: We identified container. Contacted Kuwait facility to search, had agent from CID in Kuwait to collect... cont #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: You mentioned when he was confined in Kuwait, can you provide details of the search auth? #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Were they experts in this kind of investigation? Mander: Yes. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: What did they say? Mander: Ongoing discussions best practices for investigating classified info, advised CID. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Spoke with advisors early in our investigation. One US attorney Eastern District of Virginia #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: What about DOJ started to investigate #WikiLeaks? #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: State Dept involved immediately because of nature of info obtained in chats. A month into FBI became involved. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Camp Liberty, Army CID and Dept of State then FBI became involved and joined investigation. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Who is the primary lead CCIU for WikiLeaks? #Manning |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Did Lamo receive benefit? Mander: Not that I am aware. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Both of those people told law. One was in Army. One sent an email to our office account, left name. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Person Lamo talked to told someone on a project he worked on, and a friend of his. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Initial information started investigation. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Give me one sec. Just being very careful with my notes. |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Was he working with CID at the time? Before or after? #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: How was he aware? Mander: Not aware. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Lamo contacted CCIU unknown individual was chatting with someone else. Don't know if he met that person. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
2 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Mr. Lamo contacted CCIU about Mr Katz boasting about helping to decrypt. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Would he not also require the cooperation of others to post to (indecipherable)? Mander: Not if he owned site. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Did my client possess ability to upload from his cube in Iraq? Mander: Yes. Could uploaded to multiple sites. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Depends on charge. "something by himself" Other charges require interaction with others. #Manning #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Is it your determination, would u agree that my client would have been unable to do this by himself? #Manning #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Founders, owners, manager of #WikiLeaks. Was WikiLeaks in this case? Mander: Yes they are involved in certain aspects. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Who else did u uncover doing wrong doing? Mander: 7 other civilians FBI potentially involved dont know what FBI has determined #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Yes. June 9 - Nov 2011 Had other cases would try to keep up. while on this. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: And is it true that this was the only case you were working on? How long? #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont ...Agents collecting info thought relevant, then we would go back with new info, reason for numerous visits. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: This was not a typical investogation. One issue no forensics, or they were ongoing... cont #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Anyone followed up? Som ppl told me you interviewed them 5 or 6 times, they were irritated. Typical? Mander: No not typical #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Other people contacted/interviewed by CID? Mander: Fair number. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont ...Look for info to prosecute. Were others involved. Military records showed #Manning had lived overseas prior joining Army |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont... Friendships he may have had, great deal of concern about foreign intel service. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Why would his childhood be relevant to the investigation? Mander: It turned out not to be... cont #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: So this is just from reports? Mander: No. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Re cables, 2 agents went to Dept of State, did you accompany? Mander: No. 1st grp went to collect 2nd provided by State Dept #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: When did Lamo start to cooperate with CID? Mander: (Look at choice of words, not definitive) 'Probably' at end of May 2010 #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: I do not know if Mr. Katz contacted Mr. Lamo. I do not know if they had direct contact. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Re Mr. Katz I dont believe CCIU directed Mr. Katz. That was FBI. #Mander |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Did you have any interaction with Mr. Katz or Mr. Lamo? Mander: Mr. Lamo contacted with Special Agent Edward CCIU. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IMO, this case is a move to try to checkmate #WikiLeaks. #Manning is a pawn. (back to coverage) |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Also use of all arms to build case against #Manning and WikiLeaks, but deny info and witnesses. |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
And also reinforcing the call for the Investigating Officer to step down and recuse himself, since he is a DOJ civilian employee. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def particular line of question eroding the govt justification for segregating #Manning case from DOJ case against #Manning and #WikiLeaks |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Special agent Aims was my supervisor, the others were peers. Def: You were not directing them? Manders: No #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: So agent did analyze path to Garani? Mander: Agent Wilbur CCIU at this time, do not remember report. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Re Lamo, detainees at GTMO, Garani, 2007 Apache, all that you did not see? Mander: I did not conduct analysis. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: So when talking re analysis on media in Iraq? Mander: No. (Names need verification) Agent Shaller, Johnson, Spec Agent -- #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: In some cases at aunt's house, collected with her consent then searched authorization later. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Not just search authorizations but federal magistrates? #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: Primary roles? Mander: Search authorization, interviews and administrative tasks. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: (Names need verification) Agent Aims and Agent King acting operations officers. (Needs cross check with Rainey) #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...numerous locations of investigation activity. This instance case agent on paper, supervisors took more active role. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...Normally in CID typically one agent, case agent, manages leads in case. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense: You are a case agent? Mander: Yes. Defense: Lead case agent? #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: She verified. Next up Defense examination of Mander. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Spilt room into 2 parts, photographed were item found, placed on bed. Asked Aunt she could look at items verify were his. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: We identified numerous digital media, all those items were selected. Most important on SD card various classified data. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Find anything else? Mander: Yes Search in June room had no organization. She org his items into plastic containers. #Manning |
3 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: What did the aunt tell you? Mander: Unopened, saved box allowed us to go into basement to find other items. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: By that time, Manning was transfered and effect sent to his aunt's home, signed by his dad. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Hold up with the admin The authorizing authority for warrant said we shouldn't need one because of possible harm. cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: The facility said that we needed a warrant to search those effects. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: In October a package came from the confinement center in Kuwait. After #Manning apprehension and confinement they collect personals |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...she could not use that computer. Prosec: Did you collect that? Mander: Yes. Prosec: Visit again? Mander: Yes. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...anything he sent her while in Iraq. Upstairs in her room was computer powered on while he was in Iraq... cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Yes. His belongings were obtained in basement room, looked through that room, specifically digital media... cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Did you searched that residence, since it was the place of residence in his personel file? #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: #Manning had contacted Aunt to ask her about 2007 Apache video, and second to ask her to make a posting referencing 2007 Apache vid |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...circumstances of enlistment prior to apprehension. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Discussed a wide range of topics family, where mother from, how he was brought up... cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Identified through personel file. Myself & four other agents as well as Dept of State about what she may know. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: What sorts of leads did you pursue? Mander: About June 18 2010 involved in contact and interview #Manning's aunt. |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Centaur is a govt name for netflo logs. Connection logs to and from, time and date, length... #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Did you try to collect more from ODNI? Mander: Keywords people searched. Also Centaur logs based on IP address. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...ODNI Office of director of national intel. Pros: Did you collect logs from CIA? Mander: Yes. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosec: Did CID collect logs from IntelLink? Mander: Collected disk from personel there from IP address govt work station...cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: IntelLink allows people to find classified docs. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Obtained firewall logs. During initial attempt to get log files one person at State Dept said IntelLink. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Second week of June, 2 CCIU agents obtained circle log files...obtained IP locations of where state dept stored... #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Encrypted and Password protected. File appeared to be same video. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Was identical. File called B.zip Within that file EEZPAX.wmb (he wasn't sure about .wmb) video file #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Did CID get auth to search? Mander: CID and FBI obtained Fed warrant to search & did that search on govt wrk station #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: ... additionally related to obtained forensic img auth by connection agreement w government assigned & personal computer #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Reason for being fired for engaging in inappropriate computer activity. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Mr. Jason Katz had previously been identified at Brookhaven National Labs, employed Feb 2009 to March 2010. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: How did you verify? Mander: Lamo was able to Mr. Jason Katz...cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...worked for DOE which we believed was #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Lamo contacted related became aware on Internet of someone that he did not know, original decryption effort...cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: The file was BE2PAX.zip that file was believed to be Garani airstrike video. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Several weeks later Deputy (indecipherable name wrote SJA Shonittels) provided background info on Garani airstrike. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: So CCIU sent 2 Centcom in Florida where obtained log files related to investigation. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...and that was collected as evidence. CCIU determined not sufficient. #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Garani vid believed to have been on shared -- by Centcom. Initially, CCIU attempted to connect & download those docs...cont #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Theater with 100 seat. EMPTY. And it pisses me off. |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Hearing needs witnesses. Transcription needs multiple ppl to ensure precise. Gallery not empty, I should rephrase that just seats available |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
And while we are at it, why the fuck is gallery and theater nearly empty. Journalists too grandiose to go in as public. |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
One sec. Trying to construct so as accurate as poss, based on my own notes. Remember double check against Rainey's forthcoming #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
And the next part (he was talking very fast was him saying how they investigated based on that 'intel') #Manning |
4 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
So to clarify, he is saying that the information was from the chat logs. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecutor: What did CID do? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: 2007 Apache airstrike video, info about Afghan war logs, detainees of GTMO, mentions of state dept cables. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecutor: What did you find? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: I believe corresponding info found from PFC #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Found anywhere else? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: CCIU obtained chats from Mr. Lamo and collected computer belonging to Mr. Lamo...on those hardrives. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: The majority of the investigation plan based on Lamo of #Manning and other doc obtained from personel file. |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: I inventoried all items and carried them into CCIU room. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Back to pretrial --> Mander: Items custodian'd from Iraq to Dulles (Please verify airport with Rainey Reitman) Intern Airport #Manning |
5 hours ago |
ioerror Jacob Appelbaum |
@ |
@carwinb There is no internet connection in the US that is very far from the NSA. |
5 hours ago |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Moving to where there is better internet connectivity. You would think being so close to NSA...? |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...comus leads, & tech nature matter more suited to CCIU. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Determ for search warrants & special warrants needed from Fed judge (he mentions Google and Twitter)... cont #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Why was it transfered? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: cont...Policy one office relating to another. Initially opened by the office in vicinity. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Why Iraq and not CCIU? Mander: Initially allocation was Iraq because that is where the crimes were committed... cont #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Initial investigation started by Camp Liberty, then CCIU became involved. Prosec: Role? Mander: Case agent on investigat #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: How many cases at CCIU? Mander: 20 cases. Prosec: When did you become involved? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Mander: Attended training at Defense Computer Crimes Center, courses in collection of computer evidence. 300 hours of training. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: What computer training have you completed? #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: How many cases: Mander: Me and others (he advised) 200. Been with CCIU (computer crime inv unit) 4 years. #Manning |
5 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution est credentials with line of questions. Mander: Became a CID in 1994 with 7 year break, in total approx 10 years. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: If at any time during your testimony you feel your answer is classified please inform the IO. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Sworn in by Overgaard female prosecutor: "Do you swear to tell the whole truth..." #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Recess was taken. Hearing called to order. Witness 3 Agent Mark Mander (sp. not sure) In person. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO cont: Please do not discuss this case. If someone tries to discuss this case with you, please report. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Thank you Special Agent Robertson. You are permanently excused. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Why did you not travel to Iraq? Robertson: It was determined it was not needed. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: So no imaging? Robertson: Not to my knowledge. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: He secured some network logs, which are official communications b/w computers. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution: Who was Captain Churesco (Sp. Turesco? Shorecko?) and what did he do? #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I corrected last tweet. Robertson sais he did not recall if there were multiple user profiles on some of the computers. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Come across this? Robertson: Don't know. Def: On computers you worked on were there multiple user profiles ? Rob: Don't recall #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Are you familiar with the global address list? Robertson: Yes. Def: Part of your work? Robertson: No. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Di you come across any evidence #Manning was gay? Robertson: No. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: If you could keep questions to evidence...as to what he found. Special Agent Robertson, please answer question. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: You either know or you don't. [Objection raised by Prosecution as to relevance.] #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Any evidence he was homosexual? Robertson: I don't know how to answer that question. Def: During examination? Robertson: IDK #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson con't "I know PFC #Manning referred to himself as fragile in chat logs." |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: That he wanted to become Brianna Manning? Familiar with the name? Robertson: I knew PFC #Manning had behaviors. |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Did you come across evidence he suffered from gender identity disorder? Robertson: Not qualified to make determination. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Did you send software products or instructions to Captain Churesco (Sp. Turesco?) Robertson: Don't recall. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: Yes, it is customary practice to obtain network logs. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Is that typical practice to instruct people on how to obtain network logs (this line was why didn't Robertson go to Iraq)? #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: I did not, people on my team may have instructed him. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@GeorgieBC hah ok. Thanks. |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Did you instruct Capt Churesco (sp. Turesco?) on how to conduct forensic investigations? #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Were the computers password protected? Robrtson: Only PFC Manning no, all others yes. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Cat Card access? Done during full forensics. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Beyond forensic imaging and preliminary forensic, you did not do full forensic? Rob: That's right.#Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Cat Card access? Robertson: Not sure. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: All forensic imaging done by me. Def: Take Notes? (No one could hear answer. Checked with Rainey) #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: At the time of investigation were your certifications up to standing? Rob: Yes. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Change up. If I get @carwinb in twitter jail. I will finish up on @devernaclep #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: I did preliminary analysis not full forensics. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Asks for difference b/w imaging, and full forensic? Rob: Imaging versus Full Forensics takes months. Scientific Process. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: So you don't know if the computers were used by other individuals? Robertson: No. #Manning |
6 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Robertson: Took word of investigating authorities. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Are you sure only Manning used the devices? Know if this computer was assigned to #Manning? |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: Why didn't you travel from Germany to Iraq? Robertson: The items came sealed. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Def: You weren't involved in collection, only evidence? Robertson: I collected harddrives, everything else by other special agent. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
After all documentation collected, (he himself did not collect) he imaged, and performed preliminary NOT full forensic. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Special Agent Robertson came from Computer Crimes Investigation Unit in Germany. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Second Witness, also via telephone. Special Agent Robertson. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(Alexa side note, by the way the US government uses NCase.) #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Note: I was physically present for the remaining six ours of transcription. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
At one point IO, "Last chance for govt to verify & authenticate." Defense obj., "Not IO's place to remind govt how to do there job" #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
There is no way to be sure that Tony Graham was not referring to her notes during the examination and cross #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I need to make note that witnesses are not allowed to have notes during examination. This was conducted via telephone. #manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
That info includes #Manning penetrating .mil and .gov for over a year. 'I can't say for sure if he was doing it.' |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
All her info related to affidavit her came from Quantico & 'confidential source' through chain of command... #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Back to the 'confidential informant' who was the basis of #Manning pretrial confinement #torture |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO overruled the prosecution's objection #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense said, it is really important to take that information, because it may lead to an understanding of motivation. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Pamphlet and peer review Flight into Masculinity, were not seized (this needs verification with Reitman's transcription) #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense came back as it relates to "diminished capacity" (which was thread through later in email #Manning sent a superior. |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Tony Graham testified finding a pamphlet from Canada & a peer review article about gender identification, prosecution challenged. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense was questioning if there was any evidence of diminished capacity. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense asked Tony Graham, if they found evidence of mental illness? #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Then Tony Graham said, "I don't know if the proper term is "transvestite." #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
It is not clear if she knew the difference, because when asked if she knew #Manning was gay, she said 'We knew before arrived." #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense asked her if she knew #Manning was gay or suffered from gender identity disorder #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Tony Graham was pulled May 27 2010 to collect all devices, canvas, and in depth interviews. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The prosecution set up her credentials. She had tried 100 cases per year since 2005. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Question still remain: Is the 2007 Apache video classified or not? #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(Personal note. It was an explosive day.) #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Graham also based her affidavit on an article about WikiLeaks in Stars and Stripes, a military magazine. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
According to testimony Graham was not sure then and now if info is classified. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The only information that Sp Agent Tony Graham verified was his clearance. #Manning |
7 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Her understanding of classification came a 'confidential informant' not knowledge. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense challenged affidavit that lead to #Manning's pretrial confinement. As follows... |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Special Agent Tony Graham's affidavit was the basis for #Manning pretrial confinement and was challenged for errors and her actual knowledge |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
She also seized personal laptop, camera, and external harddrive. #manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
... CD's (one titled 'secret' inside commercial cover, inside of a shipping box) #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
...scanner and computer of a friend, she "had reason" to think #Manning used, 2 more from office... con't |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
She seized several computers and CDs incl: One assigned to Manning, 2 from facility reason to think Manning used, cont #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Based on testimony she collected interviews of ppl including those in foreign locations. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Sp Agent Tony Graham first witness. Wrote affidavit authorizing order for search & seizure related of #Manning's CHU housing. |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I conferred and checked with Rainey Reitman's version who was present for that portion, as well as others. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Misspelling Rainey Reitman. Sorry. Typo. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Early morning session up to start Overgaard's examination of Agent Robertson, I was not present. Info from courtroom source notes #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I am going to tweet as yesterday and then pull together in longer form. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Its possible, but not certain that defense could be setting up a plea for Bradley based on their questions related to #WikiLeaks #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Ray McGovern sat behind me at end of day, Daniel Choi to my left. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Bradley did not engage again with gallery prob on advice. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Randy Reitman has also transcribed an account if day one and two that will post on bradleymanning.org #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I am drafting now. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Defense raised a series of interesting questions about #WikiLeaks role in act. Strategy was not evident. Could go multiple ways... #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Also, Other gov't sources, govt investigation of #Manning and #WikiLeaks |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
A lot of new info for public as to Jason Katz who was named in testimony. #Manning |
8 hours ago |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I was in attendance at #manning pretrial hearing today. Pulling notes togther. Just got out. |
9 hours ago |
jegerentwit lablu∞z |
@ |
@carwinb Nate's comment made it on Lerher. #GoNate #FreeBrad |
16 Dec |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@celhassani the man wasn't escorted out. He left on his own, and was just told he wouldn't be allowed to come back in, |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I'm delirious. Been up since Thursday. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I recount all six hours with recess beginning here scroll down, then @usdor (a back up holding page) when locked out for too many tweets |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@meowrz thanks I mean that. You are very good to me :) |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The corruption didn't end with the Iraqi PM... #freebrad #dec17 youtube.com/watch?v=6MZi1Z… #opHorizon |
16 Dec |
usdor usdor ☮ |
I have one now. Being there. Endless gifts this year. Change or die. #Revolution |
16 Dec |
Retweeted by carwinb |
usdor usdor ☮ |
. @carwinb was locked out. Am over at @usdor #Manning |
16 Dec |
Retweeted by carwinb |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Anyone who has practiced for more than a day...if individual hears something... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 3x defense has asked. 3 x you refuse. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: Defense has argued harm would come to client if certain details made public. Affect fair trial #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 3.) Ruling on 'closure' (of trial) unchanged #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Number 3... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't "...a 'reasonable' individual would consider that biased' (NB This is important legal language, 'reasonable person) #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't '...THEN this morning 2 more approved to detriment of the defense to prepare in a case that involves DEATH penalty... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't ...of the 38, only 2 defense were granted con't #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: Defense had 19 ps of relevance for each of 38, 10 that were gov't witnesses & granted... con't #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 2.) Every one of the govt witnesses were granted. Just names. No basis, YET you granted all the witnesses.... con't #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Number 2... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't ...you deny, but listening to the facts, you are NOT impartial... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't... DOJ has not ruled out fact they would NOT rule out taking this case... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs con't ...on going criminal grand jury...they would get a plea to go after Julian #Assange... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 'Your position as prosecutor for the DOJ, a 'career prosecutor' since 2002 coupled with ongoing criminal grand jury... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Number 1... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(I was a stunning delivery, beautifully executed.) |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Under RCN902A Defense asks that you recuse yourself." RCN902A 'just the mere existence of bias' as follows... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(Then a thing of beauty appeared in the court room - personal commentary) |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO continues : "Just because something reported in paper, doesn't mean its true." |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: Any discussions? IO: Not that I recall. Coombs: Any opinions? IO: No...generally no. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Any impressions prior?" IO: "Recall if allegations were true, serious matter." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "Aware some articles, some TV coverage Since Dec. (2010?) made a point of not reading anything." (dates seem confusing, sorry) #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "What prior knowledge do you have of the matter?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Answer to last tweet from IO coming up. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Have you responded to any email for the DOJ since the time you were put on leave, perform any work for the DOJ?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: So up until Dec X (12?) 2011 you were working at the DOJ? #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Dec X 2011. ( I am not certain on the date stated in Dec. I believe my scribble says Dec 12, 2011) #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs asks when the IO was mobilized, put on orders. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 'Did you inform him you would be the IO for Manning's pretrial?" IO: "Yes. I did." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Discussed this information with anyone (referring to pretrial)?" IO: "Supervisor" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Have you been exposed to this info (re: DOJ case against #Manning)?" IO: No. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@emirjame Investigating Officer. Start from bottom. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Yes. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Are you aware the DOJ has a case against my client?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: From my notes 2002- 2004 trial atty 20 cases prosecuted. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Maybe date error here, because Alonzo is on military leave at present to IO this pretrial from the DOJ. con't #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs then asks IO reserve Lt. Col. Paul Alonzo how long he has been in civilian employment with the DOJ. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "That is EC, all guilty." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "How many court martial have you performed?" IO: 6 all guilty. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 'I was an instructor there. Did I ever teach you?" IO: No, not that I recall. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@emirjame These are from notes. No electronic devices allowed. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
In this line of question, Coombs seemed to cross examine the IO in a very subtle but dramatic manner. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: 'When did you undertake the Judges course?" IO: First answer "April 2010 Course" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Did you receive any other advice?" IO: "Not that I recall." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "This is what I recall." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Email and Convo 1.) Transfer Request Disclosure 2.) Statement (?) 3.) Rules of the defense - extenuating or mitigating evidence #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Which issues did you seek legal advice on?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Who is your legal advisor?" IO: "Holzer" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Missed one question related to when he was informed... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "Col. Henley (sp.) asked if I was available, after I said yes, I was informed." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs "How did you become aware of the case as the IO?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Last personal interjection: IO, think a suaver more educated version of Gonzales if he came from California and not Texas. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs rises and walks to the podium in the center of the courtroom, facing IO. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
(personal interjection...hahahahahahahahahah) Sorry, I am not impartial. Back to the facts. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs: "Yes." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "Any challenges?" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
THEN, wait for it... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO "No known correspondence except with counsel re administrative" #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "I am an impartial fact finder" "At time I was appointed I knew very little about case. No substantive knowledge. #manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO repeats his own duties, using phrases "I will impartially evaluate...consider the evidence impartially" like a mantra #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Who do you wish to represent you? Manning: Major Kempkis (sp.) and Captain Bashard (sp.) and Coombs. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: "Do you understand your rights?" #Manning: "Yes, sir." |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Military counsel can and will be provided to you at no charge. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
NB If my feed ever goes out, I will continue on @usdor. This one is still working. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Or remain silent. Or make an unsworn statement. Any statement can be used against you. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: Right to legal representation. If non military counsel not at expense of government. Right to make a statement #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO: You have a right to be present (with qualifications re behavior). Right to call witnesses. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Next IO speaks in protocol reciting #Manning's rights. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO reads charges. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO "PFC Manning do you have a copy of the charges?" #Manning: "yes, sir." |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
IO makes a recomm to convening authority major general linnington, who will then refer to judge, and make final sentence #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Between you and me, he is a judge of sorts. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
This hearing is to determine whether there is sufficient evidence to recommend or dismiss court martial, and what kind. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The investigating officer is not a 'judge', and does not have to be a legal expert. #manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lt Col. Alonzo (here out IO as in Investigating officer). #manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs answers Nov 20, 2011 #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
There is the matter of the Lt. Col transmitting to #Manning's defense and then Manning's receipt. What is the receipt? |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lt. Col. Paul Alonzo speaks, call to order. Protocol speaks to defense. When did #Manning receive notification of pretrial date? |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Once again. This is in order, but may be incomplete. Taken from notes. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Pretrial begins. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Manning's other military defense is Matthew Kempkis (spelling) #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lt. Col. Paul Alonzo walks in as Investigating officer. He is a reserve. He works for DOJ in child protection advising on policy. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Two MP soldiers in back. One named Wright and another Bishop. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Fein (main prosecution speaker today) bound stack of papers on table with name written on the stacked edge, like a hs text book. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Prosecution comes in, Field(male blond caucasian), Overgaard(female joan crawford eyebrows caucasian), and one other (name in bit) #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Coombs arrives dressed in suit sit to the left of #manning from back. In total 2 miltary, and coombs Bradley is in between them. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
All in all the MP are friendly and firm, but their are a lot of observers. I just assume, the gallery is being observed too. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Instinct says, bailiff looking guy, totally look like more than a bailiff, confers with MP Bradley (not #Manning) seated near defense. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
50 ppl in gallery. 20 media, 30 public. in theater out of 100 seats, 35 I was told. More expect tomorrow, Sunday etc. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Media entered, they have red badges and carry brochures blue and red covers. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
In courtroom, Lt Hughes is definitely in charge of the army mp's (about 6) standing guard at back. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Couple of older vets are talking to Rainy outside about #Occupy which is surreal. Like last week, Subway lady reading article in NY'er |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Told court martial happen all the time in the building. No temporary. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
2 rear camera, 6 frontal cameras for stream to theater. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Courtroom had frosted microwave glad panels where 'air vent' would be in place right above pews. Camera? #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Funny. We see what we are. Courtroom, no windows. I leaned near shade and heard foil, looked behind blind, sure enough. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I was smoking a cigarette next. We were reprimanded. Warned press will say they are only rec button, but getting entire convo #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
At one point later in the day and NBC reporter asked to take a picture of Clarks' "Free Bradley Manning Button and lego truck #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
"Media" was instructed they could only shoot through the tunnel at entrance. #Manning. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The entrance of the building was tunneled by white tarp event tents. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Waiting outside Federal police man said to the crowd of 20 waiting. If hearing becomes unclassified you will be escorted out. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Jackson is Col. Jackson. #manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Guards at building entrance. "They are setting up, once they are done, you can go in." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Learned later Jackson was a friend of Coombs. Seemed to have a relationship with American external counsel for Assange. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Heard a discussion about Jackson (Omar Kahdr's defense). Lt Hughes "Unless Coombs coms and says something, Jackson waits." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Fed police officer ran around an shepherded people from trailers to the courtroom. Waiting entry to courtroom after metal detector #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
DHS & US government intelligence sector individuals that approached my co worker, should have just sat in the gallery. Waste $$ |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Numerous press were there including members of the international press. Spoke toa German reporter about US Day of Rage and OWS. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Also , Rainey Reitman, (for ast bit Clark Stokley - WL Truck driver, OWS Flame Pants, Ann Wright, Nate and other vet for peace). #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
In gallery: Jen Robinson, a female lawyer American external legal counsel for Assange, Jackson (Omar Khadr's defense)... #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
In the courtroom, 50 x 50 room. 4 small pews in gallery at back. (more on that later). #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
He looked up, I smiled, and he smiled back, but just barely. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
His voice was strong & respectful. At once point during a recess I walked to the left of the pews in the gallery to catch his eye. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
He looked healthy, like he had an exercised upper physique. He only spoke to answer investigating officers answer, "Yes, Sir." #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Smiling talking to one of his military defense. Skin was soft & dusty pink. Wore black army iss spectacle & dusty grey green camo #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
#Manning was seated next to one of his military defense on entering courtroom. He did not engage at all, perhaps on advice. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I will skip the details for long form about environment, how I was led to courtroom and commentary for long narrative #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Tried to transcribe play by play. Inevitably, not being expert in uniform military code of justice, may be errors or incomplete. #manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@jegerentwit yes |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Today, I felt like a witness to history. What an honor and privilege. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Last tweet before I relocate. At the end Nate from veterans for peace yelled "manning you are a hero." then exited not to return. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
6 hours many recesses. Jen Robinson was in Gallery. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Manning looked healthy smiled a lot did not engage gallery. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Took detailed notes and will find a place to transcribe to twitter starting in about ten minutes. I will then write long form #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I have just spent the entire day in the court room eight feet from #Manning it was amazing. Coombs was amazing. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
See you all later . I'm going in for real. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
No food or beverages. No electronic or Rec devices. No firearms. No chewing gum. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Obviously no smoking. :( #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Soldier told me I will get in. Opens at 7am no one in line. I came back to car to smoke a cigarette. No gum allowed either. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Ok. Gonna try to get in. Barricades moved. #Manning if you don't here from me. I got in. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Building where manning pretrial will be held next door looks like a public primary school in a suburb. One story brick. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Theater where public viewing is small brick building with one of those signs that you see in small town America outside church #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
@ |
@GregLBean no sign on Kevin G. It's first come first serve for public, but I am here very early. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Still dark on the base. Sun is coming up. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Leaves me a bit concerned. I will not be relieved until I am in public theater. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
When I asked where private manning's trial would be not everyone at vehicle inspection knew #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
... From visitor control. I drove up to vehicle inspection before 6:30 they let me in. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I get the feeling that there isn't a clear protocol for public for this event. Yesterday informed by pao that I need day pass. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I was told that the public viewing theater would be open at 7am on 29 minutes by the lady soldier over by courthouse. #Manning |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I was instructed at the vehicle inspection that I am not allowed to take photographs on the base. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
The theater where public viewing will be held is surrounded by barricades. They are arranged to facilitate a line of ppl |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
There is no live tweeting. No recording or electronic devices are allowed in public viewing theater. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
No one really hear except cars, filling up. I'm getting in line even so. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I was told they would do a physical person search to gain entry. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
I brought pen and a small notebook in case I am allowed. The public are to be seated in a theater I'm the building next to pretrial. |
16 Dec |
carwinb Alexa O'Brien |
Lady soldier give me once over and directed me to where I need to be. |
16 Dec |
Sunday, December 18, 2011
Bradly Manning tweets from @carwinb
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)